Jury awards more than $16 million to small business

On May 7, 2009, McDowell, Rice attorney Tom Buchanan won a $16,738,500 victory for ICE Corp., a small Kansas manufacturer of aircraft de-icing controllers. ICE sued corporate giant Hamilton Sundstrand and its French affiliate, Ratier Figeac, for misappropriation of ICE’s trade secrets. The lawsuit involved development and sale to Airbus of de-icing controllers to be used on military aircraft.

After a month-long trial, a federal jury in Topeka, Kansas found in favor of ICE and awardedcompensatory damages of $4,795,300 under the Kansas Uniform Trade Secrets Act. In addition, the jury found the misappropriation was willful and that punitive damages should be awarded in the amount of $10 million against Ratier and $2.5 million against Hamilton Sundstrand. Following a subsequent bench trial, the United States District Court independently evaluated the punitive damages and imposed punitive damages of $9,590,600 against Ratier and $2,397.650 against Hamilton Sunstrand. Judgment has been entered in ICE's favor, and the case remains pending for the Court’s decision on the defendants’ post-trial motions.

Jason Buchanan second-chaired the trial, and Linda McFee assisted throughout the litigation.

ICE Corp. v. Hamilton Sundstrand Corp., 615 F. Supp. 2d 1266 (D. Kan. 2009).


Known for our expertise in business litigation, commercial transactions, bankruptcy and financial restructuring, our attorneys possess diverse backgrounds and legal expertise.